For small to large enterprises, payroll software automates every stage of the payroll process. It makes it simple to set up direct deposit, withhold payroll taxes, and maintain accurate records (so you don’t get fined) for your employees. Collecting the proper paperwork from employees, ensuring you keep the relevant records, withholding deductions and taxes, and providing you compute everything accurately may be time-consuming and error-prone. 

Manual payroll can be problematic significantly since the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) penalised businesses than $4.9 million in fines in 2019 for issues like failure to pay and faulty checks. We looked over 15 different payroll software options to help you choose the best one for your company. Cost, ease of use, essential integrations, convenience, reporting options, and support were all factors considered.


Gusto is the best overall pick since it offers four bright tiers for small to midsize businesses that want payroll with a few helpings of human resource (HR) capabilities. Each package provides online tools full-service automatic payroll that can be customised to fit the needs of practically any business. Gusto is comparable to other payroll software systems in that it allows you to pay your employees via direct deposit or checks. It also automatically records and submits federal, state, and municipal taxes. Gusto differs from the other options in that it provides a better plan as you progress through the tiers. Rather than eliminating direct deposit for the cheapest plan, Gusto makes a direct deposit more convenient as your project becomes more expensive (e.g., direct deposit takes up to four days to clear for the lowest plan, but the high-tier plans get next-day direct deposit).

Gusto’s Basic plan is $19 per month plus $6 per employee per month, making it one of the most cost-effective full-service payroll options. The Core plan increases to $39 per month, but the cost per employee remains the same, and you can now provide a two-day direct deposit and health insurance alternatives. You’ll be able to gain helpful software integrations as well.

Paychex Flex

Paychex Flex

Paychex Flex has over 160 reports to help you gain a clear picture of your salaries, taxes, turnover, and more. Paychex is our top reporting option because it checks practically all of the boxes for reports and data in payroll software. It also submits your payroll taxes automatically, allows you to do unlimited payroll runs, assures compliance, and integrates with other key programmes you use, such as accounting and benefits apps.

Paychex has a lot of positive aspects. The payroll software makes it simple to set up and handle payroll, automates the submission of federal, state, and local payroll taxes, and provides numerous upgrade options that you may require as your company expands. Still, Paychex’s basic reporting may be worth the monthly charge on its own, giving it the edge in this category. 

Plus, thanks to custom fields, you’ll be able to add any extra data field you want, which is uncommon for small business online payroll services. It’s difficult to estimate how much Paychex will cost you without first requesting a unique quote. The cheapest package is $59 per month + $4 per worker per month, which is more expensive than most other small business payroll solutions (plus, vital you don’t get all those special reports). One of the most significant features of a solid online payroll solution is its ability to interact with other software. Paychex works with QuickBooks and Xero accounting software and a variety of health insurance and benefits apps, time and attendance software, and HR software.



If you currently use QuickBooks for accounting, QuickBooks Payroll is the simplest option to set up because everything will be automated. It will be a user-friendly tool for any QuickBooks user. Because the training and knowledge base is so comprehensive, you’re unlikely to need to contact support for assistance. Even if it doesn’t work, a short search on the internet will lead you to many walkthroughs.

Because its user interface is so intuitive for anyone familiar with QuickBooks, it gets our vote for the most effortless setup. Aside from customer service, many online tools are vital to helping anyone get started with their payroll services. QuickBooks does an excellent job of making payroll setup and management straightforward for everyone, regardless of experience. You’ll pay for QuickBooks’ superb capabilities, even if its HR options are a little limited. The cheapest package costs $45 per month + $4 per month for each additional person. The Premium plan costs $75 per month + $8 per person per month, but it includes HR help and a payroll setup review from a professional. QuickBooks’ Elite plan costs $125 per month plus $10 per employee per month, and it includes 24/7 support and tax penalty protection.


To summarise, We looked into three different payroll services before settling on the top eight. Cost is one of the most crucial factors to consider in any organisation, so it was factored significantly into each option. We chose this company because of its advantages such as instant deposit and reporting. We also looked for solutions that provided excellent support to aid business owners with questions about setting up and running payroll. I hope that this blog helps you choose the best payroll software and was worth a read.

Share this Link:
Call for Help & Support